Small businesses are putting more time and money into marketing, and fewer of them feel sure it is working. Constant Contact's research shows the gap clearly: the 2025 survey found confidence falling, and its Q1 2026 report found owners planning to spend even more. This guide sets out the figures, with the year beside each one, then shows how a South West WA owner in Busselton, Bunbury or Margaret River can measure what actually brings in customers.
What the Latest Data Says About Effort and Confidence
The most recent Constant Contact data shows effort rising while confidence stays low. Here is what the two editions reported, with the year of each figure:
| Finding | Figure | Year and source |
|---|---|---|
| Owners who feel "very confident" in their marketing | 18%, down from 27% the year before | 2025, Constant Contact State of Small Business Marketing |
| Owners who increased their marketing budget | 37% | 2025, same survey |
| Top frustration | Not knowing what drives results (23%) | 2025, same survey |
| Owners expecting a bigger marketing budget | 68% | 2026, Constant Contact Small Business Now (Q1) |
| Owners expecting to spend more time on marketing | 74% | 2026, same report |
The 2025 figures come from a June 2025 survey of 2,500 small business decision-makers, run for Constant Contact by Ascend2 Research across several countries including Australia. The 2026 figures come from a survey of more than 1,500 owners across the US, UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand. These are global samples, not WA-only numbers, so read them as a pattern. The Q1 2026 report published no new confidence figure that we could confirm, so 18% remains the latest comparison.
Why More Effort Does Not Create More Confidence
Confidence drops when you cannot see which activity produced a customer. Constant Contact's 2025 survey named "not knowing what's working" as the top frustration, and the pattern is easy to picture locally. A Busselton electrician posts on Facebook, runs a small Google campaign, updates the website and prints flyers. When the phone rings, nobody knows which of those four efforts caused it.
Time is the other squeeze: 42% of owners in the 2025 survey had less than an hour a day for marketing. Our article on declining organic social reach in Australia explains why one of those channels, unpaid social posting, often gives owners the least to measure. The most measurable place to start is your Google listing, and our Google Business Profile optimization guide covers setting it up properly.
Track Calls, Forms and Messages First
The most useful number in your business is the count of real enquiries, and you can collect it by hand. Before touching any software, record every new enquiry and ask one question: "How did you find us?" A simple notebook or spreadsheet works for a builder in Dunsborough or a cafe in Augusta.
- Date and name (or just a first name) of each new enquiry.
- How it arrived: phone, web form, message, walk-in or referral.
- What they said brought them to you: Google, Facebook, a friend, a sign on a ute.
- Whether it turned into a booking or a job.
After a month you have a first honest picture, and it costs nothing.
Use Google Business Profile Performance as Your Local Scoreboard
Your Google Business Profile shows how many people called, asked for directions or clicked your website straight from Google. According to Google Business Profile Help, the Performance page reports calls (clicks on the call button), directions requests, message conversations, website clicks and, if you use a booking provider, bookings. It also lists the search terms people used to find your business, and that list updates at the start of each month.
Google notes that the view counts on this page can be lower than other figures because each person is counted once per day. Watch the trend from month to month rather than every single visit. For a wider view of what helps you appear in local results, see what works for local SEO in Australia in 2026.
Set Up GA4 Basics for Your Website
Google Analytics 4 tells you which sources send visitors to your website and which visitors take an action you care about. Two settings do most of the work for a small business.
- Key events: according to Google Analytics Help, a key event is an event that measures an important user interaction, and you mark it by starring the event under Admin, then Events. Mark the actions that matter to you, such as a completed quote form. Google allows up to 30 key events on a standard property, and marking only affects reports from that point on.
- Default channel group: Google Analytics sorts visits into groups such as Organic Search, Direct, Organic Social, Paid Search and Referral. Comparing enquiries by group shows where visitors come from.
Ask your web developer to confirm that a form submission or a tap on your phone number is recorded as a key event. If neither is, your analytics shows visits but not results.
Focus on Fewer Channels
A small business is better off running two channels well than five channels loosely, because each channel needs time to set up, track and improve. That is our judgement, not a statistic. A Margaret River winery might pick Google Business Profile plus Instagram. A Bunbury plumber might pick Google Business Profile plus a short Google Ads campaign.
Constant Contact's 2025 survey found that 44% of owners named email their most effective channel, up from 23% in 2024, so an email list of past customers is worth considering as one of your two. In the 2026 report, 68% of owners expected social media to be their most valuable channel and 41% expected email, which shows what owners hope for. Your own scoreboard decides.
When one channel is clearly producing enquiries, that is the time to add budget. Our ads and campaign strategy service can help you decide where paid support fits.
Build a Monthly Scoreboard
One page, reviewed monthly, turns guesses into decisions. Track the same six numbers every month.
| Number to record | Where to find it |
|---|---|
| New enquiries (total) | Your own enquiry log |
| Enquiries by source | Your log, matched to "How did you find us?" |
| Calls, directions, website clicks from Google | Business Profile Performance page |
| Form submissions or tapped phone numbers | GA4 key events |
| Visits by channel | GA4 default channel group |
| Jobs or bookings won | Your quotes and invoices |
Compare each month with the one before and note any change you made, such as a new offer or campaign.
Your Measurement Checklist
- Every new enquiry logged with its source.
- Phone number, website link and opening hours correct on your Google Business Profile.
- Business Profile Performance page checked once a month.
- GA4 installed, with form submissions and phone taps marked as key events.
- No more than two main channels at a time, and a monthly review in the diary.
What This Means for Businesses in South West WA
Spending more on marketing only pays off when you can see what it brings in. Start with the enquiry log this week, check your Google Business Profile Performance page, and decide which two channels earn your time. If you would like a second opinion on what is and is not being tracked, our free digital audit is a good place to begin.
- Constant Contact: The State of Small Business Marketing, Effort is Up While Confidence Has Declined (3 September 2025)
- Constant Contact: SMBs Are Doing More Than Ever. So Why Is Confidence Failing? (2025 report summary)
- Constant Contact: Faced With Inflation, Small Businesses Are Doubling Down in 2026 (Q1 2026)
- Google Business Profile Help: Understand your Business Profile performance and insights
- Google Analytics Help: Mark events as key events
- Google Analytics Help: Default channel group
Want help turning your marketing spend into enquiries you can measure?
See Ads & Campaign Strategy โ